Tags

How to Professionally Critique Your Boss at the Annual Review

  • critiqueboss

 

No boss is perfect. But is it a good idea to tell him/her so? After all, you might be setting yourself up for retaliation, or called a complainer. However, there are ways to do it with class and tact. If your supervisor's behavior is hindering productivity, you owe it to yourself, the team and the whole company.

 

Bring notes. At a time when you're calm and objective., write down the points you want to bring up — and stick to them. Speaking off the top of your head, in the heat of the moment, is more likely to cause hurt and anger than any beneficial behavior change.

 

Ask if he/she would like feedback. Prepare your boss for the discussion with a polite lead-in. If he/she just doesn't want to hear criticism at all, or will be insulted no matter how nice and positive you try to be, it's better to back off. If you believe the situation is putting the team or company at risk, handle it another way, such as through HR.

 

Focus on your perceptions. Don't make direct accusations: "You bully us in meetings." Instead, say that this is how you interpreted the behavior, which may not be how your boss intended it. "I feel that you don't value our input in meetings."

 

Stick to specifics. Blanket statements such as, "You're always micromanaging us" are not informative or helpful. Give some examples of occasions when his/her micromanaging delayed production or harmed morale.

 

Put it in terms of his/her goals. You're the one who looks bad when you say, "Your long lunches are forcing us to work late." Instead, say something like, "If you took a shorter lunch, we could get more done and exceed the team's quotas."

 

Make clear that you may not see the whole picture. Sometimes a supervisor's actions are in response to directives or conditions you're not aware of. If he/she is introducing a new way of doing things or a new team organizational structure, explain what you're uneasy about and suggest that more communication from him/her would ease tensions.

 

Don't give an eye for an eye. When you get a negative review, it's tempting to throw responsibility for it back on the boss. "If he gave me more guidance, I wouldn't make so many mistakes." Before you risk ruining your working relationship, take an honest look at yourself. Also, make sure that other people under his supervision also see the problem. Then you'll know it's really him, not you.

 

Critiquing your boss can be scary. But if you approach it the right way, and both of you are open to the process, your relationship will be stronger and more productive than ever.

Tags

You might be interested in...

5.09.17
Stay Organized and Take Back Your Life
  How much time do you spend every day hunting for something that's not where you thought you put it, looking at the same paperwork as yesterday, or jumping from one project to another without finishing any of them? This is pure wasted time, and you have better things to do with it.   These tips aren't about getting organized in the first place — setting up tools and systems. You probably have some already, or at least some idea of what you need. It's about actually using your organizers so that they simplify your life as they're supposed to, not just add more clutter.   1. Organize as you go. Take a tip from professional chefs who constantly clean their workstation so that they can maintain maximum speed and efficiency. The instant you're finished using your comb or that client file, put it back in its rightful home. At the end of the day, you'll be free to enjoy your life with no big, messy pile demanding your time and attention.   2. Segregate your activities....
Read More
5.02.17
It's Mental Health Awareness Month — So Let's Talk About It
  It's estimated that one in four people in America has a mental health issue at some time in their lives. Yet, even though it's so common, nobody wants to talk about it — either their own or anyone else's.   That's too bad, because talking can often reduce the fear, shame and anger people might feel towards someone suffering with mental illness, and go a long way towards helping the sufferer feel better too.   Is there someone you need to start a conversation with? Here are some tips.   Plan a good time. Right in the middle of a busy day is not the moment to suddenly say, "I have something important to tell you about myself" or "I've noticed you seem really down/stressed/angry lately." Pick a time when both of you will have at least 30 minutes for uninterrupted talk.   Be prepared for a discouraging reaction. Many people are extremely uncomfortable talking about mental health, or may be in denial about their own situation. They might push you away with, "you're...
Read More
General

Title

More Info
You need an account to do that Set up an account Never Mind

Please register for an account first. If you already have one, log in here.